The Cupcake Cottage - Fresh Homemade Goods

Serving Central Indiana & beyond • Est. 2025

Baked to feel like home again

From my Kitchen to Your Table

Cozy, small-batch treats made with ingredients you can feel good about, from everyday favorites to gluten- and dairy-free bakes.

Browse the Bake Shop Our Story

Explore

Subscriber Access

Get first access to drops, pre-orders, and announcements

Enter your email to unlock the full experience with The Cupcake Cottage — track orders, get notifications, and more.

Benefits:

Track orders
Live chat with The Cupcake Cottage
Customize notifications
Benefit from loyalty rewards

The Cottage Difference

Quality, trust, and community at the heart of everything

🍪

Serv-Safe Certified

Certified for safe baking

🧁

Always Dye Free

Colored by Nature

⭐

5 Star Home Bakery

Loved by local families

Cottage Favorites

The sweet staples behind countless local celebrations

Featured

Floral Cupcakes

Delicate, handcrafted, and almost too pretty to eat. Our floral cupcakes are topped with intricate buttercream blooms, piped by hand using smooth, from scratch buttercream and naturally inspired colors for a soft garden-style finish. Perfect for birthdays, baby showers, bridal showers, Mother’s Day, weddings, or simply because flowers make everything feel a little more special. Each set is designed with a mix of floral styles, textures, and seasonal color palettes to create a beautiful cottage-inspired presentation. Available in vanilla, chocolate, funfetti, lemon, and seasonal flavors. Gluten friendly, dairy free, and egg free options are also available upon request. Please note: • Floral designs are custom and no two sets will be identical • Color palettes and flower styles may vary slightly based on your selections • For highly specific floral requests, inspiration photos are encouraged A sweet centerpiece designed to feel both elegant and homemade.

$58.00

View All Products

From my Kitchen.

I started The Cupcake Cottage because I wanted to be home with my girls and still create something of my own. When I couldn’t find treats made with ingredients I felt good about serving, I began remaking the classics in a gentler, dye-free way. Before long, I realized other families were looking for the same kind of baking.

Behind the Bakes